对比原著

A

你看过《红楼梦》的电视剧和原著小说吗？感觉哪个更符合你的期待？

Nǐ kàn guò 《Hónglóumèng》 de diànshìjù hé yuánzhù xiǎoshuō ma？Gǎnjué nǎge gèng fúhé nǐ de qídài？

Have you watched the TV series and the original novel of "Dream of the Red Chamber"? Which one meets your expectations better?

B

我看过87版电视剧和原著，电视剧更注重视觉效果，原著则更注重人物刻画和情节的深度。各有千秋吧。

Wǒ kànguò 87 bǎn diànshìjù hé yuánzhù，diànshìjù gèng zhòngshì shìjué xiàoguǒ，yuánzhù zé gèng zhòngshì rénwù kèhuà hé qíngjié de shēndù。Gè yǒu qiānqiū ba。

I've watched the 1987 TV series and the original novel. The TV series focuses more on visual effects, while the novel focuses more on character portrayal and plot depth. They both have their merits.

C

我个人更喜欢原著，因为它更完整更细腻，电视剧为了时间限制很多情节都删减了，有些人物的性格也做了调整。

Wǒ gèrén gèng xǐhuan yuánzhù，yīnwèi tā gèng wánzhěng gèng xìnì，diànshìjù wèile shíjiān xiànzhì hěn duō qíngjié dōu shānjiǎn le，yǒuxiē rénwù de xìnggé yě zuò le tiáozhěng。

I personally prefer the original novel because it's more complete and detailed. The TV series had to cut many plots due to time constraints, and the characters of some figures were also adjusted.

A

是啊，我同意你的观点。原著的语言更优美，更有韵味。

Shì a，wǒ tóngyì nǐ de guāndiǎn。Yuánzhù de yǔyán gèng yōuměi，gèng yǒu yùnwei。

Yes, I agree with you. The language of the original novel is more elegant and has more charm.

B

不过电视剧的演员选角和服装造型都挺好的，也更容易让人接受，特别是对不习惯阅读长篇小说的年轻人。

Bùguò diànshìjù de yǎanyuán xuǎnjiǎo hé fúzhuāng zàoxíng dōu tǐng hǎo de，yě gèng róngyì ràng rén jiēshòu，tèbié shì duì bù xíguàn yuedú chángpiān xiǎoshuō de niánqīng rén。

But the casting and costumes in the TV series are very good, and they are also easier to accept, especially for young people who are not used to reading long novels.

C

哈哈，这倒是真的。这就像不同的艺术表现形式，各有各的优势。

Haha，zhè dào shì zhēn de。Zhè jiù xiàng bùtóng de yìshù biǎoxiàn xíngshì，gè yǒu gè de yōushì。

Haha, that's true. It's like different forms of artistic expression, each has its own advantages.